Whether the language was, in fact, disrespectful. To facilitate order and discipline society as a whole need laws. Failure to salute, showing disdain, insolence, indifference, rudeness, impertinence and undue familiarity also constitute disrespectful behavior to the superior. It is sense a discipline and duty that keeps the United States Army so effective. If the superior officer’s conduct with the accused is not in line with accepted standards, then the latter may not be charged under Article 89 even if he has exhibited disrespect for the superior.

Often it is these customs and traditions, strange to the civilian eye but solemn to the soldier, that keep the man in the uniform going in the unexciting times of peace. That accused may not be convicted of being disrespectful to the officer who has so lost the entitlement to respect protected by Article I had offered the suggestion of eating at the food court of the PX. I told him that he promised not to drink. The victim may not fall within the narrow definitions of a superior commissioned officer. Although UCMJ is just one of the tools used to monitor a military personals conduct, it is the most important because of it being the base for all of military conduct.

Any person subject to this chapter who- 1 violates or fails to obey any lawful general order or regulation; 2 having knowledge of any other lawful order issued by any member of the armed forces, which it is his duty to obey, fails to obey the order; or 3 is derelict in the performance of his duties; shall be punished as a court-martial may direct.

Article Disrespect Toward a Superior Commissioned Officer

The specific disrespectful behavior should be alleged. How about receiving a customized one? The accused may say in his defense that he was unaware that the other was a superior officer.


I was debating weather to get beer or something non-alcoholic. The makeup of an Army leader is a strong intellect, physical presence, professional competence, high moral character, and serves as a role model. Leave your email and we will send you an example after 24 hours It is deemed that the superior has lost his entitlement to respectful behavior owing to his own undesirable conduct.

Although UCMJ is just one of the tools used to monitor a military personals conduct, it is the most important because of it being the base for all of military conduct.

He may also mitigate reduction in grade to forfeiture or detention of pay. Whether the accused knew that the victim was a superior commissioned officer. The stakes are your life! In such case, the term ‘superior officer’ refers to the commanding officer or any commissioned officer of the same armed force who carries superior rank and is not inferior in command to the accused.

When mitigating— 1 arrest in quarters to restriction.

article 89 ucmj essay

In war they keep him fighting at the front. That the behavior or language indicated disrespect to the superior officer under the circumstances prevailing at that time.

Article 89 ucmj essay

Customs include positive actions-things you do, and taboos-things you avoid. Truth is no defense. That the person who was the subject of the words or behavior was a superior commissioned office to the accused. Whether the acts, omissions, or words were actually directed towards the victim.

Some of the things that are artixle illegal in regular sociality that are highly frowned upon are illegal articlw the standers that we as soldiers live by.

Disrespect of an Nco and Disobeying a Direct Order

The accused is punished as deemed right through a court martial process. The appeal shall be promptly forwarded and decided, but the person punished may in the meantime be required to undergo the punishment adjudged. The term ‘superior officer’ here refers to a commissioned officer of the other armed force who is in a superior position in the chain of command when compared to the accused.


Living the Army Values means abiding by them everyday in everything we do. Your military counsel works for the same military that charged you.

Artidle victim is a commissioned officer and superior in the chain of command over the accused. Jordan travels around the globe to represent service members in military criminal defense matters.

Bryant that I understood and Agreed to fallow exsay order that was just given to me. Sorrells49 C. That the accused committed an act s or used certain words to or about a commissioned officer. Chapter 4 of the MCM coversand expands on the punitive articles.

The divestiture is limited to offenses where the protected status of the victim is an element — but may not extend to lesser included offenses [3].

article 89 ucmj essay

A victim is not a superior commissioned officer simply because he or she is superior in grade to the accused [2]. I remember thinking that Cumj. When a servicemen fails to give his superior the respect that is due to his authority and person, he exhibit disrespectful behavior as per Article